HP MicroServer Gen8 G1610T Review

HP Proliant Gen8 MicroServer
HP Proliant Gen8 MicroServer

HP reached somewhat of a cult status amongst many tech enthusiasts a couple of years ago when they dropped the price of the N36L MicroServers to clear out stock. The new price point highlighted a niche market with large growth potential, especially for those wanting to build their own whitebox NAS. At the time, popular NAS providers such as QNAP and Thecus were considerably more expensive, not to mention the MicroServers were capable of so much more than simply being a NAS.

The old N36L was based on the AMD chipset and the subsequent models N40L and N54L were based on the same with some incremental speed bumps. This new Generation 8 (Gen8) G1610T MicroServer comes sporting the Intel Celeron G1610T processor which promises to give a significant speed boost over its predecessors.

Specs

ProcessorIntel® Celeron® G1610T (2 core, 2.3 GHz, 2MB, 35W)
Form factorUltra Micro Tower
Power Supply150W non-hot plug, non redundant power supply kit Multi-output
Expansion slots1 x PCIe
RAM Slots2 x UDIMM slots
Storage BaysSupports up to (4) LFF SATA non-hot plug drives
Optical Disk DriveNone Supplied; Supports slimline optical drive
Network Controller1Gb 332i Ethernet Adapter 2 x Gigabit Ports
Storage ControllerDynamic Smart Array B120i/ZM
Infrastructure managementiLO Management Engine

Build Quality

Taking the unit out of the packaging, it’s fairly obvious that this little box is well built. The front includes 2 x USB2 ports, opening for a slimline (aka laptop sized) optical drive and swinging door that opens to show 4 x HDD bays. Gone from the front are the keys required to open the door and the spare screws on the inside of the door. The required screws are already on the drive caddies. However, using the supplied tool to remove and apply the screws was extremely painful. Do yourself a favour and get a proper torx screwdriver, it’s much faster. The drive caddy appears to be much more flimsy then the previous designs.

The rear of the unit also comes with some subtle but welcomed changes. The first thing I noticed was the removable cardboard asset tag which includes serial # and iLO default network settings. Simple but still a nice touch. The number of PCIe slots has been reduced to 1 and there isn’t a eSATA port anymore which is a little disappointing. Also included are 2 x USB2, 2 x USB3, 2 x Gigabit NICs, 1 x VGA and 1 x iLO port.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Taking the  cover off shows where most of the redesign effort was spent. The new look MicroServer takes care of all my gripes of the previous model. Gone are the days where you need to take the motherboard out of the MicroServer in order to add RAM or a PCIe card. The new design allows for easy access from the sides of the unit.

The CPU heatsink appears to be removable but I can’t confirm whether the CPU is as I’m sure that HP wouldn’t be impressed if I started to perform a teardown on their review unit. 😎 As with previous models, an internal USB is included but unlike older models the Gen8 now also includes an internal microSD slot. There is still an internal SATA port for optical disk drive and HP continues to use a mini-SAS cable for the 4-disk drive bay which means no issues with using the HP P4xx series RAID controllers.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Setup & Configuration

With in the inclusion of iLO with the new MicroServers, setting up the boxes has never been easier. Similar to the old RACs (Remote Access Cards) used in the N series, the integrated iLO allows you to remotely configure the server.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

iLO uses .NET, JAVA and a mobile client where the old RACs used JAVA only to perform KVM functions. One issue I came across was that you actually need to buy a license to get the remote control working. Without a valid license, you get a couple of minutes before the warning box pops up and kills off the session. For the purpose of this review, I popped over to the HP site and grabbed a free 60-day evaluation key, which seemed to work for one time use only?

gen8ms_20
iLO License Required

Running FreeNAS on the G1610T MicroServer

There are a range of NAS solutions available that can run on most PCs. For the purpose of this review I used the latest 64-bit version of FreeNAS. I currently run the older version on my N40L and N54L MicroServers. The installation onto a USB thumb drive was went as expected and was mostly problem free. On first load, the server was not publishing an IP address for the web config page but a reboot later all was good. Everything was recognised and the NICs were also capable of being configured for LAGG/LACP. You will need a supported switch to take advantage of this feature.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Running ESXi 5.1 on the G1610T MicroServer

According to Intel, the G1610T CPU supports VT-x but doesn’t support VT-d. ESXi 5.1 Update 1 was installed to a bootable USB thumb drive to see how virtualisation performed anyway. On installation I hit one small snag, it needed more RAM to complete the install process.

2GB RAM Not Enough
2GB RAM Not Enough

The amount of available RAM from the supplied 2GB wasn’t enough. Fortunately, I still had an old 2GB stick from my N36L that I could use. After that it was all a fairly simple process with no issues. The first onboard NIC was detected no problems, the 2nd refused to be detected for some reason. Also, as expected no VT-d support so no DMA remapping of SATA ports, etc… You are still able to map USB devices to a host.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Final Thoughts

The MicroServer comes with a lot of features packed into a tiny box. If you were to build your own, the difference in cost would be negligible and not worth the effort considering what you get as a whole plug and play package from HP. The internal design was much better than the old N-series MicroServers. The relocation of the memory slots for easy DIMM changes was a nice touch. The only negative for me was the drive caddy being a little too flimsy. Overall, I liked the HP MicroServer G1610T. A mini server suitable for most non-enterprise needs.

Did you like this?
Tip Noeneel Sharma with Cryptocurrency

Donate Bitcoin to Noeneel Sharma

Scan to Donate Bitcoin to Noeneel Sharma
Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some bitcoin:

Donate Bitcoin Cash to Noeneel Sharma

Scan to Donate Bitcoin Cash to Noeneel Sharma
Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send bitcoin:

Donate Ethereum to Noeneel Sharma

Scan to Donate Ethereum to Noeneel Sharma
Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Ether:

Donate Litecoin to Noeneel Sharma

Scan to Donate Litecoin to Noeneel Sharma
Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Litecoin:

Donate Monero to Noeneel Sharma

Scan to Donate Monero to Noeneel Sharma
Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Monero:

Donate ZCash to Noeneel Sharma

Scan to Donate ZCash to Noeneel Sharma
Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some ZCash:

Post Author: Noeneel Sharma

Australian born tech expert, Noeneel, is the founder of the GeekLingo. He has over 25 years of experience in the Information Technology (IT) world. As an Information Technologist, he has a Bachelor in Information Technology, MBA and a Master of Business Process Management. He has professional working experience working in reputable industries including telecommunication, legal, accounting, banking, and most recently electricity. He spends most of his time with his gadgets as he enjoys photography, researching and cryptocurrencies. Connect with Noeneel on Google+, Twitter, and Facebook.

14 thoughts on “HP MicroServer Gen8 G1610T Review

    Nicolau Kaje

    (October 19, 2013 - 9:06 am)

    I did buy the same server and not able to install freenas, keep crashing when it detects the internal raid.

      Noeneel Sharma

      (October 20, 2013 - 2:51 pm)

      Have you configured RAID in the BIOS? Let FreeNAS create and manage the RAIDZ array. If you’ve got a RAID0-5 created, FreeNAS won’t like that as it needs direct access to the HDDs.

    Ram

    (November 5, 2013 - 3:18 pm)

    I have an issue installaing Freenas / Nas4fee on new HP Microserver Gen8 (G2020T). It boots well with Live CD and once i create USB (Freenas) and try to boot, I get following error “BTX – Halted”. If try with Nas4Free, the server restartes automatecally, while initial USB booting. Note: Currently built-in RAID configured (RAID1). Thanks in advance for you help. Regards, Ram

      Noeneel Sharma

      (November 5, 2013 - 3:20 pm)

      Don’t use internal RAID, let FreeNAS manage the RAID itself.

    Ram

    (November 5, 2013 - 4:32 pm)

    One question before I try: Should I delete existing RADI-1 from array configuration utility and try booting freenas from USB? or do I need to change some settings in BIOS before this USB booting. Regards, Ram

      Noeneel Sharma

      (November 6, 2013 - 10:47 pm)

      If there is no data on the RAID then yes, go for it.

      Cathal

      (December 22, 2013 - 6:40 am)

      Did it work without the BTX Halted?
      regards Cathal

        Ram

        (December 23, 2013 - 12:08 pm)

        Yes, it works, but fan speed goes bit high with out raid config.

    Rene Rodriguez

    (November 28, 2013 - 2:05 am)

    did anyone have problems with 5.1 not seeing any of the NIC for the 322i Ethernet adapter? Can seem to get the install even going because it swears theres no nic there.

    Andrei_I

    (December 14, 2013 - 12:52 am)

    I have an issue with 5.5 and 322i NIC. the Server is constantly disconnecting by itself. I am trying now to create a custom installer package for Esxi and hope I manage to insert the driver in the image. I’ve found a nice tool to customize ESXI images , called: ESXI-Customizer version 2.71.

    Bjoern Koeckert

    (December 7, 2014 - 6:37 am)

    Is it possible to use the USB3-Ports with Freenas?

    Anusha Dharmasena

    (April 1, 2016 - 11:31 am)

    Hi I’m planning to get this for home NAS. I will be using Windows Server 2012 R2 Essentials. Can you install the OS and setup everything using iLO? The issue is, I only have a laptop with me: so, no monitor and keyboard.

      Noeneel Sharma

      (April 1, 2016 - 3:39 pm)

      I haven’t tried Windows Server but I was able to do a headless install of Linux.

        Ram

        (April 1, 2016 - 4:00 pm)

        Windows 2012 R2 is supported

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.